Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Academy: Collision Course (SPOILERS!)

I mean it:


Judith and Garfeld Reeves-Stevens are reliable writers. They know Star Trek. They can write. So there's always at least some pleasure to be had from the Shatnerverse novels. The problem, which may be their co-author's fault, is that the stories are so damned preposterous that there's just no way I can reconcile them with my sense of what actually happens in the Trekverse. (IOW, they don't fit into my personal continuity.)

Now, when you have a resurrected superhero version of James T. Kirk running around the 24th century and showing Jean-Luc Picard how to save the galaxy, preposterous is pretty much the starting point. Going back to the young Jim Kirk seems to offer the chance for a more realistic and believable kind of story. Something that could appeal to readers who find the 24th century Kirk stories just too hard to believe. Or you could just get a preposterous story in which the Kirk who saves the day and shows everyone how it's done happens to be a teenager.

Unfortunately, we get the latter.

Okay, maybe it doesn't strain credibility too much to have Kirk and Spock meet as teenagers before either joins Starfleet; canon doesn't give us any detail on how long they've known each other or when they first met. And canon doesn't say much about Kirk's brother, so maybe he was a drug addict involved in an alien crime ring before he ended up on Deneva with Aurelan and the kids.

But the idea that Kirk is a genius engineer and hacker, estranged from his father, just doesn't quite feel right to me. The idea that, even before joining Starfleet, he manages to steal the Enterprise from Spacedock and fight the bad guys and blow open an Orion conspiracy... well, that's where we go from "I'm not sure I buy that" to "this is utterly preposterous." James T. Kirk is not just some guy, sure, but making him so much of an overachiever so early takes away from the Hornblowerish self-questioning and self-doubt we see in some TOS episodes.

The portrayal of Spock as a somewhat insecure teenager still not fully in control of his emotions is solid and believable. He's handled pretty well in the story, but I'm not sure the Vulcan artefact smuggling that he stumbles across is really thought through. The bad guys are knowingly buying supposedly stolen forged Vulcan artefacts with tech that fools sensors into showing them as authentic in order to get the tect to use it for another purpose. But how did the process start? Did the bad guys think, hey, let's try to steal Vulcan artefacts, so they'll create fakes with the kind of tech we need? Did the Vulcans think, it is logical to assume that our artefacts may be stolen, and therefore they should all be replaced with forgeries equipped with technology that will enable them to deceive the thieves and their sensors? Maybe that was addressed somewhere and I missed it, but it felt like Braga/Menosky TNG/Voyager plotting: come up with a mystery, add a twist to the mystery, add a surprising explanation to the mystery, but don't look at it chronologically to see if it would actually make sense.

I did like the way the story dealt with the backstory from "The Conscience of the King." It explains why a farm kid from Iowa was on Tarsus IV, it explains why only a small number of survivors could identify Kodos (instead of everyone who wasn't killed during the incident), and it gives the young Jim Kirk some somewhat surprising but plausible characterization.

Two groups of people may be a bit annoyed by this book for reasons that didn't bother me. First, the Enterprisephobes will find a considerable number of references to the prequel series in this book. Second, if I'm remembering Diane Carey's novels about Kirk's father correctly, fans of those books may be disappointed that Collision Course is not consistent with them.

So... overall, a mostly fun romp that's ultimately as preposterous as the 24th century Kirk novels. For me, that's a bit disappointing.


At 5:57 PM, Blogger Keith R.A. DeCandido said...

Not to complain overmuch, but....

This is your first substantial post since May. In the intervening months a mess of cool books have come out, from Reap the Whirlwind to the conclusion of the Vulcan's Soul trilogy, a whole mess of TNG books of various stripes, not to mention a bunch of eBooks, plus the 2008 schedule was announced, with lots of cool stuff on it.

And this is what rouses you to post again? A new Shatner book?


At 7:51 PM, Blogger Steve said...

Oh, don't worry. I do intend to cover more important matters, once I've read The Sky's the Limit and Before Dishonor.

At 9:04 PM, Blogger Keith R.A. DeCandido said...

Oh good. :)


Post a Comment

<< Home